the gar spot

fiction and musings from a gay black dude with delusions above his station

Menu
  • About
  • Privacy Policy
  • SIN AGAINST THE RACE, a novel
Menu
the gar spot fiction and musings from a gay black dude with delusions above his station

Privilege Dies Hard

Posted on February 26, 2013 by gar

So we all know the story now.  The Onion made a series of irreverent, snark-filled tweets during the Oscars.  And then they demeaned a nine year old.

The joke, so say knowledgable comics, was to take someone innocent who is doted on and then turn that very innocence on its head, to say, in effect, you think she’s this, but in reality she’s that.  Waka, waka, waka!

The crickets that normally follow a bad joke did not materialize.  Instead a fierce and might storm of tweets soon erupted, causing whoever posted the stupid tweet about Ms. Wallis to take it down an hour later.  Because of course, this comment was more than just a bad joke.  As Salon noted in their headline, it was quite vile.

We also know that The Onion came clean and issued a full and complete apology, where they took ownership for the mistake, apologized to Ms. Wallis by name, admitted how vile the incident really was, and said they would take steps to keep such things from happening in the future.  This was not one of those “I’m-sorry-you’re-offended” apologies or even an Endora apology, this was the real deal.  Good for The Onion for coming clean about it.

I actually find defenders of the Onion’s boneheaded tweet almost more disturbing than the tweet itself.  BuzzFeed reported on a couple of former Onion staffers who did not like that The Onion apologized at all.  Former Onion editor Joe Garden said:

“My reaction was, ‘It wasn’t a great joke, but big deal.’ I saw where they were going, and the commentary was about the media construct and the Oscar hype in general.”
-Quoted in BuzzFeed

Those who make such observations tend to live in a world blind to the fact that women and girls, particularly women and girls of color, are subjected to such demeaning language regularly.  Or worse, they rely on the tired cliché, ‘yeah, well, women are called things like that, but then this was only meant as a joke, not to be taken seriously.’  Wrong.  Similarly, trying to contextualize the “joke” in the framework of Oscars hype doesn’t fly.  Had the target been an adult, it still wouldn’t have worked.  The remark would have still come off as crude and tasteless.  And the offended woman would likely have told them as such in short order.  But the target was a nine year old girl, someone who by definition could not have defended herself.  That’s cowardly. There is no context where it’s OK to call a nine year old girl the b-word or the c-word.  Period.  Don Imus learned a similar lesson the hard way.

So Mr. Garden’s statement is a fail.

Worse, though, was this tweet from another former Onion staffer:

Steve Hannah will use this to shuttle last shreds of editorial say from creative–>management & ad sales. Cunt is the onion’s reichstag fire.
-Quoted in BuzzFeed (same article)

So he’s saying that current Onion CEO Steve Hannah will use this tweet as an excuse to jackboot down, Nazi style, on The Onion and make it his fascists fool’s paradise.

Wow.

But that is what he’s staying.  What he’s alluding to is the infamous fire which destroyed the German Reichstag building in the early days of the Nazi regime.  In fact the fire, the origins for which scholars continue to debate to this day, occurred on February 27, 1933 (80 years ago this Wednesday, in fact), a mere month after the Nazis came to power.  Adolf Hitler used the fire as a pretext to suspend civil liberties, clamp down on opposition parties, and basically turn the country into the genocidal Nazi dictatorship it became and remained until the end of the war in 1945.

Wikipedia states that the term “Reichstag fire” has become an archetype for any disastrous event that can then be blamed on hated political opponents as a means of discrediting and destroying them.  They cite an example from history where an event lead to the persecution of Christians in an ancient civilization located in modern-day Turkey, an event that modern historians refer to as a “4th century Reichstag fire.”

So the question becomes, does the apology and disciplinary actions taken at the Onion for a dumb, offensive tweet rise to the level of a Reichstag fire event?  Such absurd speculation merits an article in the Onion itself.  Of course it doesn’t.  As is often the case, when you have to rely on a Nazi comparison for your defense, you’ve lost the argument already.

Whenever I hear folks whining about not being able to make such-and-such a joke, at the expense of some usually oppressed person or persons, it’s always in the form of the privileged, those outside the group, complaining that they are suddenly beholden to the oppressed, the target of ridicule.

And privilege dies hard.

© 2013, gar. All rights reserved.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

SIN AGAINST THE RACE, a novel–Click image for info

Sin Against the Race

Contact

  • email gar

Twitter

Follow @the_gar_spot

Instagram

garmcveyrussell

Think of all the potential. #wordsonthestreet #se Think of all the potential. 
#wordsonthestreet #seenwhilewalking #neighborhood #walk #oakland #ilovemycity
Pride brunch. #pride #pridemonth #pridesunday #pr Pride brunch. 
#pride #pridemonth #pridesunday #prideday #pancakes #brunch
Dug up from the archives. I can’t believe we hav Dug up from the archives. I can’t believe we have to fight for this again. 
#abortionrights #abortionishealthcare #cisgaymanforchoice
Time to write more letters to encourage people to Time to write more letters to encourage people to vote. Tempus fugit.
#abortionrights #abortionishealthcare #roevwade #mymarriageisnext #voteblue #voterepublicansout
Pride flag over the Claremont Hotel. Don’t think Pride flag over the Claremont Hotel. Don’t think I’ve ever seen that before. 
#pride #pridemonth #berkeley
New outdoor dining set. #backporch #alfresco #hom New outdoor dining set. 
#backporch #alfresco #homedecor
Consulted with my editors this morning. I value th Consulted with my editors this morning. I value their feedback. 
#trees #hiking #oakland #writersofinstagram #iputmyfaithintrees
Remembering Roger Ebert on what would have been hi Remembering Roger Ebert on what would have been his 80th birthday. 
#rogerebert #writer #legend #cancersucks
Fly me to the moon (not pictured) Let me play amon Fly me to the moon (not pictured)
Let me play among the stars
Let me see what spring is like
On Jupiter (the brighter one) and Mars
#backyardastronomy #jupiter #mars #predawn #goodmorning
A gorgeous day at the #oaklandgreekfestival #oakla A gorgeous day at the #oaklandgreekfestival #oakland #greekfestival #greek #music #food #ilovemycity
I used to rock the hell out of these. Cards of dis I used to rock the hell out of these. Cards of discovery and endless possibilities. I still miss them. 
#cardcatalog #library #knowledge #og #searchengine
A sunny Saturday in 1990 found my sister Tania (@m A sunny Saturday in 1990 found my sister Tania (@makeuptogoblog) and I outside of the Julia Morgan Center waiting. I had seen the great Maestro Pt. Shivkumar Sharma in LA—he even autographed an album for me. And I was studying tabla with his accompanist Ud. Zakir Hussain at the time. We couldn’t wait. But wait we did, because the maestros weren’t there. As my sister and I stood at the front of the line, they came. Ud. Zakirji was laughing and joking. Pt. Shivji looked as if he floated in as he passed and entered the theater. After we got settled in our seats, it was on. A beautiful concert with the two maestros playing rapturously, holding us spellbound. Pt. Shivji floated in like a deity and played to the heavens, taking us all with him. By far one of my favorite concerts. 

Words cannot describe how devastated I am at the great master’s passing. His gifts to music and the world are incalculable. My condolences to Panditji’s family, to @zakirhq9 , and to all who loved his beautiful music. #ptshivkumarsharma #indianclassicalmusic #santoor #rip
This makes me very happy. #oaklandgreekfestival # This makes me very happy. 
#oaklandgreekfestival #theyreback #yahoo #greek #oakland #ilovemycity
Happy 85th Birthday to legendary Maestro Ron Carte Happy 85th Birthday to legendary Maestro Ron Carter! The most recorded bassist in history, he was a huge inspiration for my late brother Robert. And he continues to inspire bassists and musicians to this day. 
#happybirthday #roncarter #legend #bassist #jazz #music
Dinner on the back porch. #alfresco #dinner #pizza Dinner on the back porch. #alfresco #dinner #pizza #arizmendi #evening
My sacred music day where I pay homage to Duke Ell My sacred music day where I pay homage to Duke Ellington (1899-1974) and Ustad Alla Rakha (1919-2000) on their shared birthday. This year I’m also celebrating the 100th birthday anniversary of harmonica and whistling maestro Toots Thielemans (1922-2016). Enjoy the music of all of these legends! ✌🏾 ❤️ 🎶 
#dukeellington #allarakha #abbaji #tootsthielemans #centenary #happybirthday #music
Happy Birthday Ella Fitzgerald! Born on this day i Happy Birthday Ella Fitzgerald! Born on this day in 1917. 
#ella #ellafitzgerald #firstladyofsong #jazz
It’s the only home we got. Let’s treat it with It’s the only home we got. Let’s treat it with respect and love. 
#earthday #earthday2022 #home #planet #environment
A harrowing day, but it ended safely. I’m home n A harrowing day, but it ended safely. I’m home now with a nice cup of tea. ☕️ 
#berkeley #shelterinplace #allclear #home #tea #murchies
This pale blue beauty is destined to become part o This pale blue beauty is destined to become part of my #sundaybrunch #pancakes. Fresh from my next door neighbor!
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Facebook

Subscribe by email:

Archives

Blogroll

  • Life During Wartime – The Trump Years
  • Patricia Dunn – Author
  • Philip Robinson, poet
  • The Outspoken – You're Welcome
  • Uppity Negro Network

Interests

  • Cassini Probe @ Saturn
  • Daily Kos
  • Doctor Who
  • KCSM – Jazz 91
  • Makeup to Go!
  • The Root

Tags

99% african-american AIDS Bay Area bigotry Billy Strayhorn black Black Lives Matter climate change Duke Ellington dystopia dystopian fiction gay growing up gay healthcare history homophobia jazz LGBT LGBTQ literature marriage equality music North Korea novel Oakland police brutality politics queer queerlit queer lit racism rant reading Religion Republicans Romney SATR science fiction Sin Against the Race Trayvon Martin Trump women in jazz writing

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
©2022 the gar spot | Theme by SuperbThemes